Jake and Holt get arrested by Sheriff Reynolds (Jim O’Heir), a local deputy, after a misunderstanding when they purchase guns to take down Figgis. During this time, Figgis sees the viral video and captures U.S. Marshal Karen Haas. Jake and Holt eventually break out of jail and decide to call the Nine-Nine for help. Meanwhile, C.J. (Ken Marino), the new captain of the precinct, has a hands-off attitude and lets his subordinates do whatever they want. This begins to bother Amy, and she tries to get the captain to toughen up. Later, when the group confronts the captain, he refuses to give them permission to help Jake and Holt.
Original air date: September 27, 2016
Writer: Tricia McAlpin